HomeDNA DNA tests revolutionized the DNA testing industry. Since entering the market in 1995, HomeDNA has taken ancestral genealogy to the next level. Unlike most other DNA tests, HomeDNA has the technology to pinpoint the precise location of where your DNA stems from, not just the general region. With this technology, HomeDNA is able to track your DNA back, up to 1,000 years ago, to the exact village where your ancestors lived.
The HomeDNA - GPS Origins sample kit
• Genealogists tracing family history
• Those seeking a deeper personal genetic history
• Supplementing other types of DNA tests
• Report delivers pinpoint accuracy
• Migration history covers thousands of years
• Detailed background for each DNA migration point
• Color maps cover 3 top gene pools
• Chart breaks down full genetic profile
• Slightly more expensive at $149
• Fairly basic for the cost
• No genetic matching or family-finder features
A key benefit of using HomeDNA is seeing where your DNA originated. In our case, the DNA origin point was listed as near Vyshny Volochok, Russia, sometime prior to 1277 BC. The report offered 2 DNA migration paths meant to represent movement of maternal and paternal ancestors. One moved from Russia to the Czech Republic and ended at Palma de Mallorca, Spain, as late as 311 BC. The other path went from Russia to near Kalisz, Poland, and ended at Roanne, France, as late as 1095 AD. This kind of precision is very intriguing, assuming the science behind it is correct. As with other deep-ancestry kits, these results predate the availability of most genealogy research data, so they can provide some surprising additions to the family story.
• Deep ancestry tracing hundreds of generations
• A testing algorithm plotting migration paths to local level
• Color-coded maps showing top three gene pools
• Detailed chart showing all ethnic groupings
• Good historical background on regions and time periods
• A report useful for everyone from layperson to expert
HomeDNA has a different mindset from other types of genealogy DNA tests. The focus is less on ethnic groups or racial lines and more on where different populations gathered to form an individual’s DNA. In addition to the location-specific migration paths, the HomeDNA report includes a full breakdown of each person’s gene pool. In our case, the top 3 gene pools were Fennoscandia (22.4%), Southern France (21.1%) and the Orkney Islands (13.2%). These group designations were different than those used on other DNA tests. Each of the top 3 gene pools included a history article with background on the peoples that comprised them. An accompanying chart included 8 other gene pools, from Basque Country (12.2%) down to Northern India (0.1%).
The HomeDNA - GPS Origins report includes a chart with breakdown of all gene pools in your DNA.
The HomeDNA - GPS Origins collection kit was rather spartan, in contrast to most other kits on the market.
HomeDNA advertises a 4- to 6-week turnaround time once it receives a completed DNA test kit. This is quicker than for some competing kits. Some users online reported receiving results in as little as 10 days, which could be due to HomeDNA using its own laboratory for DNA processing.
Compared to other DNA collection kits we’ve encountered, the HomeDNA kit was incredibly basic. When it arrived, the “package” almost looked like a junk-mail brochure. There was no box or appreciable marketing presentation; just some test swabs wrapped in a brochure. Given the kit’s $149 price, this was rather surprising. The kit included 4 cheek swabs, but no vials in which to secure them. In fact, we were instructed to put all 4 completed swabs into the included paper envelope together. Cross-contamination was apparently not a concern for the lab. The instructions said to seal the return envelope with tape and not to lick the flap, yet the flap contained gum adhesive of the type you lick. This seemed unnecessarily confusing. There was no kit activation or advance registration; HomeDNA used information provided at purchase to identify the returned DNA sample. Again, this was confusing, so we contacted customer service to confirm the small barcode on the kit would indeed link to our name and contact information.
All 4 cheek swabs were placed in the same paper collection envelope for shipment to the lab.
The HomeDNA test uses autosomal (family) DNA for its analysis and report. In our case, the lab examined nearly 730,000 autosomal “markers” or mutations on the chromosomes and compared them with markers in the gene pools of reference populations in the HomeDNA database. By looking at where and when our DNA last changed, HomeDNA was able to provide the breakdown of gene-pool populations and the map of how ancestors migrated.
• Color-coded maps for top 3 gene pools
• Background articles on top 3 gene pools
• Chart with breakdown of all gene pools
• Migration paths of ancestors
• Google-style zoomable map with pinpoint locations for migration paths
• Background articles for each migration path
• Downloadable DNA file that can be used with other DNA services
Customer support is an important resource, especially when so many purchasers of DNA kits are new to genetic genealogy. We found HomeDNA customer service quick and responsive (replied within a day) with the one question we submitted regarding kit registration.
Regular price for the HomeDNA DNA kit is $149, although the company does offer promotions that cut the price by $50 or more. Consumers have the option of uploading a DNA file from another vendor for analysis using the HomeDNA algorithm. That option costs $79.
HomeDNA offers a compelling DNA kit and deep ancestry report for genealogists who want to delve back many generations before family records were kept. Its report gives customers a very detailed migration route that their ancestors took from a point of origin to more recent times. This test does not provide the standard ethnicity mix that comes with many autosomal DNA tests. Rather it looks at where ancestors lived, and then moved, hundreds of generations ago. The HomeDNA report gives customers actual village or town names along a migration path, where ancestors once lived.
The DNA test kit marketed by HomeDNA provides a longer and deeper genetic history than other kits that focus only on providing a person’s ethnicity percentages. HomeDNA delivers deep ancestry, looking at genetic markers to estimate ethnic origins going back thousands of years, and mapping out two migration routes that ancestors followed. It does not trace history as deeply as some tests on the market, but it gives pinpoint geographic accuracy to show where each person’s ancestors lived at various times in history.
GPS Origins was launched in 2016 as a stand-alone brand offering a unique type of genetic testing for genealogy. In 2017, it became part of HomeDNA, a web site offering a suite of DNA test products related to paternity, health and pet-breed identification. HomeDNA is based on the research of Dr. Eran Elhaik and a team at the University of Sheffield in the United Kingdom. The test uses some 800,000 genetic markers from 862 reference populations to determine the origin of a person’s DNA, down to a specific village or region. The service was launched in 2016 through a stand-alone web site, but in 2017 GPS origins became part of HomeDNA, which also sells genetic tests for skin care, healthy weight, joint care, determination of paternity, and dog-breed identification.
The laboratory work is done by DNA Diagnostics Center of Fairfield, Ohio. The company did not explain the change to HomeDNA, causing some confusion when we retrieved our results. The website and most of the marketing materials were different than when the original kit was purchased. The site is so new that on our visit there was just one customer rating for the HomeDNA product — and that was written by an employee of the company that developed the test. HomeDNA’s Twitter feed did not yet have any activity when we visited.
DNA Diagnostics Center
1 DDC Way
Fairfield, OH 45014
Phone: (800) 281-2916
MyHeritage has more than 7 billion historical documents, 300 million photographs, 34 million family trees and 2.1 billion names in family trees. This collection, while not the largest in the industry, is nevertheless impressive in its size...
Ancestry simply has no peer when it comes to the breadth and depth of information available to genealogists. Since 1996, it has amassed more than 17 billion searchable records. While the majority of these records relate to the United...
Living DNA helps customers learn the ethnic makeup of their DNA and gain some insight into their family background and where their ancestors came from. The company advertises a more sophisticated form of testing that it says combines the...
Come for the genealogy, stay for some health and diet advice. Or, if you prefer, come for health and diet advice, stay for some genealogy. That’s the basic premise behind the DNA kit offered by Vitagene Inc. Nutrition and ancestry...
The entire 23andMe experience is smooth and each touchpoint seems carefully considered. There are various options throughout the process, allowing you to feel in control. For example, you can choose to take just the “Ancestry...